Site icon Find My Fit

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices in 2024

Are you a busy cat owner in the bustling city of New York?

Do you often find yourself in need of a reliable and trustworthy cat-sitting service when work takes you away from home or when you’re planning a well-deserved vacation?

Look no further, you’ve come to the right place!

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices
Contents show


Cat Sitting NYC businesses play a crucial role for pet owners in the city for several reasons:

Busy Lifestyles: Many New Yorkers lead busy lives with demanding work schedules, social commitments, and travel requirements.

This can make it challenging to provide consistent care for their cats, especially during long hours away from home or when traveling for extended periods.

Limited Space: NYC apartments are often smaller compared to homes in suburban or rural areas.

Cats may not have access to outdoor spaces or enough room to roam freely indoors, making it essential to ensure they receive adequate attention and enrichment while their owners are away.

Peace of Mind: Leaving a beloved pet alone for extended periods can cause anxiety and stress for both the cat and the owner.

Knowing that a professional cat-sitter is caring for their feline friend provides peace of mind and reassurance that their pet’s needs are being met in their absence.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

Specialized Care: Cats have unique needs and preferences, and not all pet sitters are experienced or comfortable caring for them.

Cat-sitting businesses typically employ professionals who are knowledgeable about feline behavior, health, and care requirements, ensuring that cats receive specialized attention tailored to their individual needs.

Emergency Preparedness: In the event of emergencies such as natural disasters, medical emergencies, or unexpected travel, having a reliable cat-sitting service on standby ensures that pet owners have a backup plan in place to ensure their cats’ safety and well-being.

Socialization and Enrichment: Cats are social animals and benefit from regular interaction and stimulation.

Professional cat-sitters can provide companionship, playtime, and mental stimulation to prevent boredom and loneliness, promoting a happier and healthier lifestyle for the cat.

Home Security: In addition to caring for the cat, cat-sitters often provide basic home care services such as bringing in the mail, watering plants, and rotating lights, which can help deter burglars and ensure the security of the owner’s property while they’re away.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

Key Takeaways:

why you need to trust us

Finding the right cat sitter for your furry companion is essential. It greatly affects your pet’s well-being and your peace of mind.

Our aim is to provide a thorough guide to make this process simple and confident.

When evaluating cat sitter options, we focus on reliability, expertise, and how well they meet your cat’s unique needs and personality. We also emphasize transparency and trustworthiness in our suggestions.

With my 28 years of experience in business management and as a cat owner myself, I am well-equip to help you find the ideal cat sitter for your beloved pet.

If you are in search of a cat sitter, you are unquestionably committed to ensuring the best care for your feline friend.

Top 5 Cat Sitting NYC Businesses:

In the fast-paced urban landscape where every moment counts, finding a reliable and trusted cat-sitting service is paramount for pet owners seeking peace of mind and exceptional care for their feline companions.

In this section, we shine a spotlight on a selection of top-notch Cat Sitting NYC businesses that have earned acclaim for their professionalism, expertise, and dedication to ensuring the well-being of cats across the city.

Kitty in NY

Kitty in NY is dedicated to assisting pet owners in discovering the ideal personalized service for their feline companions.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

Their services offered, inclusive of in-home cat boarding and cat sitting, are meticulously tailored to meet every aspect of the client’s requirements.

Each caregiver undergoes a stringent selection process, ensuring they are handpicked to specifically cater to the needs of the cats.

With an extensive database of cat boarders and sitters, Kitty in NY guarantees that every cat is matched with the finest care providers in the industry.

Prioritizing safety, each recommended caregiver and home undergoes thorough inspections.

Clients can expect receiving periodic updates, including both videos and photos, from their designated caregiver during their absence, guaranteeing their cats feel right at home.

Covering areas including the Bronx, Queens, Brooklyn, and Manhattan, Kitty in NY’s services are designed to address the unique needs of each cat.
Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

For information regarding rates, clients are encouraged to visit their website.

Services Offered

Features from Kitty in NY

Reviews & Testimonials:

“Jose was patient and responsive, and the cat sitter they sent us was wonderful–very responsible and helpful.”

“I felt at ease right away based on our caregiver’s prompt, thorough, and caring style of communication with me.”

“Due to u expected events, we contacted them last minute and we were able to secure an amazing cat sitter.”

Google Rating: 4.7/5

Website: Kitty in NY – Cat Care Services in New York

Rates: Kitty in NY

Locations: Kitty in NY serves the boroughs of Manhattan, Brooklyn, Bronx, and Queens, providing top-notch care for cats in these areas.

Additionally, they offer a limited number of caregivers in New Jersey, ensuring that clients within an easy commute to Manhattan can also benefit from their services. Furthermore, they can assist in arranging pickup and delivery services for added convenience.

Clients are encouraged to contact Kitty in NY for personalized assistance, as they are committed to doing their utmost to find a suitable solution for every pet owner.

Contact Kitty in NY: via online form or (718) 514 9586.

Katie’s Kitty

Kate’s Kitty, a cat sitting and boarding company situated on the Upper East Side, extends its services to Manhattan, as well as various neighborhoods in Brooklyn and Queens.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

With roots dating back to 1997, the company boasts full insurance and bonding, demonstrating its commitment to the safety and security of its clients’ pets.

Comprised of passionate animal lovers, the team at Kate’s Kitty is dedicated to ensuring the happiness and well-being of both cats and dogs under their care.

Their personalized homecare service comprises half-hour or hour-long cat sitting visits, available once or twice daily to accommodate the specific needs of each client.

For longer absences, their cat boarding and dog boarding services offer a suitable solution, with the company typically boarding only one animal per host-family home across New York City.

Unlike traditional kennel environments, where animals may be confined to cages, Kate’s Kitty provides a nurturing alternative, granting pets free reign of the host’s home, including bed privileges.

Most of their pet sitters operate from home, ensuring continuous supervision, with all caregivers fully insured and bonded for added peace of mind.

With over 35 loving host-family homes to choose from, Kate’s Kitty promises a unique boarding experience tailored to each animal’s needs.

For those seeking an unparalleled alternative to traditional NYC kennels, owner and founder Peter Lindenbaum offers a complimentary consultation to discuss individual requirements.

Services Offered


Reviews & Testimonials

“When we came home, our cats were happy, well cared for and the apartment didn’t smell like a litter box.”

“I never have trouble getting in touch with Sara and communication with Peter, the owner, is always quick.”

“Other times when I needed a sitter after moving to Queens I was lucky to be paired with a wonderful cat sitter – Sara.”

Google Rating: 4.7/5

Website: Welcome to Katie’s Kitty

Rates: a quote will be needed to determine rates.

At Katie’s Kitty, all services are tailored to meet the specific requirements of each client, with rates determined by several factors.

These factors encompass the type of service needed, the duration of the stay, and the unique needs of the individual cat. Additionally, discounts are available for boarding stays exceeding 30 days.

Locations: Katie’s Kitty offers cat sitting and boarding services in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, & Jersey City.

Contact Katie’s Kitty: via 212-288-5712 or

Cuddles and Tails Pet Services

Suzy K’s cat sitting business in NYC embodies a deep admiration, love, and respect for all animals.

With a childhood enriched by caring for a diverse range of pets, including cats, dogs, parakeets, and even a rescued crab, Suzy K was inspired to realize her vision of providing unparalleled, trusted, and loving pet care services.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

Her unwavering commitment to excellence and anticipation of clients’ needs have enabled her team to consistently deliver experiences that leave pets overjoyed during their stay at Camp Cuddles or through comprehensive home visits.

Suzy K and her team take pride in sharing their services with even more pets, ensuring they experience the unique difference and dedication offered by Cuddles and Tails Pet Services.

Services Offered


Reviews & Testimonials

“I’ve used Cuddles and Tails’ cat-sitting services many times by now, for trips ranging from a few days for a few weeks, and I can’t recommend them enough.”

“I was initially wary about leaving my two pretty neurotic cats with strangers, but Suzy, Roza and Natalia have given us such incredible peace of mind whenever we’re away.”

“They’re professional, communicative, and above all, really love cats and care about the cats in their care. Plus, as a bonus, they take really good pictures, which you’ll get a ton of every day in a delightful email. “

“Suzy and her team are the best. The photo updates and notes are so cute. Also, they are great at being able to get me in last minute.”

“For work I had multiple last minute overnight trips come up and they would be able to watch my babies even with a very short notice.  They are the best!”

“We are so grateful for Cuddles and Tails. Suzy, the founder, is amazing, she really understands animals, and she is so on top of all communication.”

It is clear that the animals are the #1 priority. I feel like I have very high expectations when it comes to the care of my girl, and I’ve never been disappointed w C and T. I would give 6 stars if possible.”

Google Rating: 5/5

Website: Cuddles and Tails Pet Services

Rates: Price List

Locations: Cuddles And Tails cat-sitting business extends its services to various neighborhoods across NYC, including East and West Village, Gramercy Park, Union Square, Soho, Nolita, Lower East Side, Chinatown, and Tribeca (up to Chambers Street).

Additionally, they also cater to some Midtown East and West areas.

Contact Cuddles And Tails: via 646.416.6538 , or

Cattitude Street Strutters

Cattitude Street Strutters has been offering personalized pet care services to clients across Brooklyn and Manhattan.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

Their steady business growth can be attributed solely to positive word-of-mouth referrals.

The company prides itself on its unwavering commitment to delivering the highest quality of care to every animal entrusted to them.

Whether it’s cat sitting, dog walking, pet sitting (including overnight stays in the comfort of the pet’s home), or specialized vet tech services for pets with health concerns, clients, both furry and human, consistently commend their services.

The team at Cattitude Street Strutters is deeply passionate about serving fellow pet owners in the New York area. As pet parents themselves, they understand the significant role pets play in their clients’ lives.

Recognizing the importance of providing peace of mind to pet owners during vacations or business trips, Cattitude Street Strutters ensures that pets are well-cared for, allowing their owners to relax knowing their furry companions are in capable hands.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

Services Offered


With respect and appreciation, Cattitude Street Strutters acknowledges the opportunity to offer a vital service, extending care to those who may lack a voice or family support.

Their mission is to surpass the expectations of clients who graciously invite them into their lives and homes, entrusting the well-being of their cherished furry family members to the care of Cattitude Street Strutters.

Reviews & Testimonials

“Taryn and her team at Brooklyn Cattitude are top notch. She is professional, the process is easy, and her fees are reasonable. Sophia took great care of our cat Snowball the week we were away on holiday.”

“She is very reliable, super friendly, a cat lover and an all around wonderful cat sitter.”

“Taryn of Cattitude goes above and beyond to help her petsitting clients!!! Cattitude is both responsive and responsible as they care for your pet.”

“I especially love the captioned photo updates that I get each day from Alex of my twin gingers, it gives me great peace of mind to know that they are properly cared for in my absence.”

“Booking is simplified with an app after an initial in-person meet and greet. Communication is outstanding. I am truly grateful to have access to Cattitude knowing that my cats’ wellbeing is their priority.”

“So happy with Cattitude’s services! I’ve used them multiple times to care for my cat, Clooney, while I was out of town. We just moved to Brooklyn and it’s such a relief to know he’s in good hands while I’m away!”

“Ashley and Cate left the sweetest notes and photos after each appointment, letting me know that my little guy was happy and safe. Taryn and the whole team are very communicative which gives me peace of mind. Thanks Cattitude!”

Google Rating: 4.9/5

Website: Cattitude Street Strutters

Rates: Price List

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

Locations: Cattitude Street Strutters cat-sitting business offers its services across a diverse array of neighborhoods, spanning Bedstuy, Boerum Hill, Brooklyn Heights, Bushwick, Carroll Gardens, Clinton Hill, Cobble Hill, Crown Heights, Downtown Brooklyn, Dumbo, Fort Greene, Greenwood Heights, Greenpoint, Manhattan (Lower, Midtown, Upper West Side, Upper East Side), Park Slope, Prospect Heights, Lefferts Gardens, Red Hook, Ridgewood, South Slope, Sunset Park, Williamsburg, and Windsor Terrace.

Contact Cattitude Street Strutters: via (718) 749-9417 or


The West Village Cat Sitter & Manhattan Kitties

The West Village Cat Sitter & Manhattan Kitties LLC (WVCS-MK) distinguishes itself apart from your typical cat sitting NYC businesses.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

While the cat sitters referred by West Village Cat Sitter & Manhattan Kitties operate as independent contractors and assume full responsibility for the care of the feline clients, they are interconnected within a network.

This network ensures that in the event of a primary sitter’s unavailability, a backup sitter can easily communicate with the primary sitter for additional information or guidance.

Services Offered

At The West Village Cat Sitter & Manhattan Kitties, clients can always expect transparency regarding the identity of their visiting sitters.

Client authorization is strictly adhered to, ensuring that no individuals will enter clients’ apartments without their explicit consent.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices


In her role as owner, Sylvie Gilbert-Pellegrin personally meets with all new clients at The West Village Cat Sitter & Manhattan Kitties. She facilitates the initial meet-and-greet between the sitters and the cat owners, ensuring a smooth introduction process.

Sylvie also follows up after these meetings to confirm that the sitters are suitable matches for the clients and their feline companions.

Utilizing a comprehensive vetting system, Sylvie conducts background checks, verifies references, and enforces a strict protocol regarding the scope of work.

This meticulous process ensures the maintenance of the high standard of service that her cat-sitter referral company is renowned for, meeting the expectations of discerning pet owners.

Reviews & Testimonials

I had a GREAT experience with the West Village Cat Sitters/Manhattan Kitties. Sylvie was wonderful to work with ahead of my trip, and the sitter, Jee, was fantastic about communication, and sent lots of photos that I looked forward to receiving every day.

“They made me feel much less anxious about leaving my cat with someone new while I was away. I would definitely use them again!”

“I am very happy with Sylvie and her team. They’re professional and responsive and it’s clear they love cats. Sylvie introduced herself and her business and made me feel very comfortable leaving my kitty in her care.”

“I am so thankful I found Sylvie (owner) and Chris (sitter). Sylvie made me feel comfortable choosing West Village Cat Sitter & Manhattan Kitties, she’s a pro and so is her team!”

“Chris was so kind and attentive to my cat, he took amazing care of her while I was away. My simply cat adored him, and he emailed regular updates every day.”

“They are awesome, provided excellent service, and are very affordable. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a trustworthy service!”

Google Rating: 5/5

Website: The West Village Cat Sitter

Rates: Basic Costs

Locations: The service locations of The West Village Cat Sitter & Manhattan Kitties cat-sitting business encompass the neighborhoods of NYC’s West Village, Greenwich Village, and Chelsea.

Contact The West Village Cat Sitter & Manhattan Kitties LLC: via +1 646-420-7676 or the General Contact Form.

Bonus Player: Who is ‘Cat In A Flat’?

Self-funded and self-motivated, Cat in a Flat emerges as a project initiated by Julie Barnes and Kathrin Burckhardt.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

As avid cat owners themselves, they encountered the common dilemma of leaving their beloved feline companions behind while going on vacation.

Recognizing the unique challenges faced by cat owners, Julie and Kathrin embarked on creating a network where true cat lovers could provide care for cats in their absence, ensuring they receive the attention, playtime, and affection they deserve.

With a vision to establish a community-based network that caters to all cat lovers, whether owners, sitters, or enthusiasts, Julie and Kathrin combine their passion for cats with their expertise in digital platforms.

As proud parents of Soda and Casper and with over 15 years of experience in the digital industry, they aim to create a welcoming environment where everyone who shares a love for cats is embraced and valued.



Recognizing the importance of entrusting one’s furry companions to individuals who truly comprehend and appreciate their needs, Cat in a Flat strives to provide peace of mind to cat owners while ensuring the well-being and happiness of their beloved pets.

Reviews & Testimonials

“Five stars isn’t enough. Luciana was amazing. Not only did she do a wonderful job taking care of our cat, but she kept us updated every single day with lots of pictures and detailed updates.”

“It made our trip SO much more relaxing to know that the cat was happy. Our cat is usually very anxious and shy around strangers, but He LOVED Luciana and so did we!” – Samantha F.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

It’s quite a leap of faith giving a stranger the keys to your home, let alone the responsibility for your beloved pet. But from the initial contact, Meylin was kind, professional and attentive.

“She took care of our shy cat for a week and regularly updated us with pictures, videos and messages. We are confident that all our cat’s needs were met, and more.” – Giles F.

“Heather was awesome whilst we were away over Christmas, returned home to find Flea very relaxed and content. Great communication from the start, really friendly and sent us lots of nice photos.”

“Would definitely recommend her and will be in touch for future trips!” – Jake C.


Cat in a Flat offers a trusted and reliable cat-sitting service, providing cat owners with access to experienced sitters in various locations.

Their service areas include Boston, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Newark, New York, Queens, and Yonkers.

Contact Cat in a Flat by submitting a ticket – right here!

Interested in becoming a Cat Sitter for Cat in a Flat? Click here!

Cat in a Flat Blogs

Guide for Cat Owners in Need of Cat Sitting: Tips, Safety, and Pricing

Explore our comprehensive guide designed for cat owners, encompassing essential tips for optimal care, rigorous safety protocols to instill confidence, and insightful pricing considerations for informed decision-making on good Cat Sitting NYC choices.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

From invaluable advice on pet welfare to strategies for fortifying home security and understanding the financial aspects of professional services, this guide equips pet owners with the knowledge and resources necessary to navigate the intricacies of cat sitting NYC businesses with professionalism and assurance.

Tips for Pet Owners:

Research and Compare:

Ask for Recommendations:

Interview Potential Cat-Sitters:

Check Credentials and Insurance:

Discuss Services and Pricing:

Provide Detailed Instructions:

Arrange a Meet-and-Greet:

Communicate Regularly:

Prepare Your Home:

Follow Up Afterward:

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

Safety and Security:

Reputable cat sitting NYC businesses prioritize the safety and well-being of both pets and homes through a range of meticulous safety measures.

These measures often include:

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

By following these tips, pet owners can verify the credibility and reliability of cat sitting NYC businesses, ensuring that their beloved feline companions receive the highest quality of care in their absence:

Check Reviews and Testimonials: Research online reviews and testimonials from past clients to gauge the satisfaction level with the cat sitting NYC business.

Ask for References: Request references from the cat sitting NYC business and contact past clients directly to inquire about their experiences.

Verify Licensing and Insurance: Ensure that the cat sitting NYC business is licensed, insured, and bonded.

Inquire About Training and Certification: Ask about the training and certification programs offered to cat-sitters employed by the cat sitting NYC business.

Interview Cat-Sitters: Schedule interviews or consultations with potential cat-sitters to discuss your cat’s needs and your expectations.

Visit the Facility: If the cat sitting NYC business operates a physical facility, consider scheduling a visit to assess the cleanliness, organization, and overall environment.

Check for Membership in Professional Organizations: Look for cat sitting NYC businesses that are members of reputable professional organizations or associations, such as the National Association of Professional Pet Sitters (NAPPS) or Pet Sitters International (PSI).

Evaluate Communication and Responsiveness: Pay attention to the cat sitting NYC businesses’ communication and responsiveness during the inquiry and booking process.

Trust Your Instincts: Ultimately, trust your instincts when assessing the credibility and reliability of a cat sitting NYC business.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

Pricing Guide:

Several factors can influence the pricing of cat sitting NYC businesses, including:

Number of Cats: The number of cats in the household can significantly impact the cost of cat-sitting services.

Duration of the Visit: The duration of each cat-sitting visit is another key factor in determining pricing.

Frequency of Visits: The frequency of cat-sitting visits can also affect pricing.

Time of Day: Some cat sitting NYC businesses may charge higher rates for visits during peak hours or holidays when demand is high and availability is limited.

Additional Services: Cat sitting NYC businesses may offer a range of additional services beyond basic cat care, such as grooming, administering medication, cleaning litter boxes, bringing in the mail, watering plants, or rotating lights to deter burglars.

Location: The location of the cat sitting NYC business and the client’s home can also impact pricing.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices


Cat sitting NYC businesses are vital supports within New York City’s busy urban landscape, catering to the diverse needs of pet owners and their feline companions.

They provide essential care and peace of mind amidst hectic schedules and city living challenges.

With expertise in specialized feline care, emergency readiness, and socialization, these businesses ensure cats thrive.

Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices Trusted 5 Best Cat Sitting NYC Choices

Additionally, they offer home security measures, protecting both pets and homes.

As guardians of the pet-owner bond, cat sitting NYC businesses enrich the lives of cats and their devoted owners in the vibrant city.

If you’re interested in some fantastic business ideas for stay-at-home moms, click right here: Mompreneur.

Or maybe you need some creative new business ideas, click right here: Business Names.


Can I leave my cat with a cat sitter?

A good option for when you have to leave your cat at home is to have a cat sitter come in every day to clean the litter box, make sure your furry friend has food and water, and provide them with some quality one-on-one playtime and cuddles.

How much do cat sitters charge in NYC?

As of May 2024, the average starting rate for a cat sitter in New York, NY is $16.31 per hour.
The weekly cost for a cat sitter working a 40-hour week in New York, NY is $652 while the monthly cost is approximately $2,120 for 130 hours of work.

Is it better to board a cat or leave at home?

Boarding your cat with professionals is probably the best option for their care while you’re away

Is it okay to leave a cat for 3 weeks?

If you need to leave for two or three days, a full week, or longer, you should make sure someone is coming over to care for your cat daily


Cat in a Flat – How it works

10 Reasons Why You Need a Cat Sitter – Houston’s Best Pet Sitters

Trusted In-Home Cat Sitters – How It Works | Meowtel

About Us — Brooklyn Cat Sitting

TOP 10 BEST Cat Sitter in New York, NY – Updated 2024 – Yelp

Home business: A good idea in 2024? A Mompreneur answers.
Starting a party rental business 2024 ? Quick Guide by Mompreneur
Best Stay At Home Mom Business Ideas By A Mompreneur

Find us on Pinterest:


This information is provided for educational and entertainment purposes only. We, Find My Fit ( do not accept any responsibility for any liability, loss, or risk, personal or otherwise, incurred as a consequence, directly or indirectly, from any information or advice contained here. We may earn compensation from affiliate links in this content.

Exit mobile version